Skip to main content
Estate AdministrationEstate Planning

If Only They Were Fairytale Problems – Modern Day Cinderella Troubles

By September 17, 2015June 5th, 2019No Comments
Drawing of Cindarella's step mom and two step sisters

When people remarry, the dynamics between children and step-parents is never over, even after one of the spouses has passed away. In cases when one spouse was a millionaire, a challenge to the will is almost expected. But one case in New York has an unexpected twist.

Aa8dbc18501f415e3e701bf590ab968aPerhaps if Dr. Nathaniel Shafer knew what was to come, he may have made some changes to his will that might have precluded a nasty dispute between his wife and his children from a previous marriage. By leaving a $10 million estate entirely to his wife and her child from a different marriage, Dr. Shafer set the stage for a battle that turned ugly fast.

Problem: Jennifer and Robert Shafer, the children from a previous marriage, are claiming that their stepmother filed a fake will. They want the court to throw that will out and to use an earlier will that leaves half of the estate to them. To prove their claim, the Shafer siblings are asking the court to waive a doctor-patient privilege so a therapist the couple saw can testify about their relationship.

The New York Post reported this story in an article titled “Siblings claim stepmom filed fake will to get $10M inheritance.”

Claims of fake wills are not quite as common as claims of using undue influence to have someone create a new will. That might be because wills are not particularly easy to fake. It is not quite as simple as merely forging the deceased’s signature. Wills require witnesses for a reason: so they can be called to testify that they did in fact see the deceased sign the will.

The original article does not explain how the siblings plan to get around the witness issue, if the witnesses are able to testify that they saw Shafer sign the will that was filed with the court. As is often the case, there may be more to this than meets the eye.

Avoid future estate administration issues by reviewing your estate planning in connection with life changes: new marriages, family additions, divorce, etc. Learn more about our law firm and your changing estate planning needs at one of our free Workshops. Attendees are then invited to schedule a complimentary hour with Attorney Thomas Hackett when he can review your current estate planning strategy and documents one-on-one. Please contact us at 360-975-7770 or at to sign up and learn more!

Reference: New York Post (August 28, 2015) “Siblings claim stepmom filed fake will to get $10M inheritance.”